American Fire

Smoke map · Brief

Kentucky mutton

Owensboro and western Kentucky still smoke mutton. It is a pillar in that county and a footnote in national roundups. If you cannot find mutton, a lamb shoulder will cook, but it will not be the same. Black dip is Worcestershire and vinegar, not ketchup.

Kentucky mutton plate
MeatMutton. Sheep that is not a lamb. Shoulder or quarter.
WoodHickory and oak.
SauceBlack dip: Worcestershire, vinegar, pepper, a little allspice. Not a tomato sauce.
PlateChopped or sliced mutton, black dip, white bread.

If you find mutton

Treat it like a pork shoulder: 250°F (121°C), hickory, wrap when the bark is set, pull near 200°F (93°C) when a probe slides. Mop with black dip late.

Black dip sketch

1 cup Worcestershire, 1/2 cup cider vinegar, 1 tsp black pepper, 1/2 tsp allspice, 1 tsp brown sugar, 1 crushed garlic clove. Simmer 5 minutes. Not a full recipe — a starting point.

Sides

White bread · Pickles · Sliced onion · Black dip

This region is a brief in the map, not a full recipe chapter.